Loading
  • HELP?
    • LOGIN / SIGN UP
    • CONTACT
    • NEWSLETTER
    • FAQ
  • ISLAY
  • TERROIR
  • TOURS
  • 0Shopping Cart
Bruichladdich Distillery
  • PHILOSOPHY
    • Progressive

    • Hebridean

    • Distillers

  • BRUICHLADDICH
  • PORT CHARLOTTE
  • OCTOMORE
  • THE BOTANIST
    • THE BOTANIST GIN

    • WILD. FORAGED. DISTILLED.

    • FORAGED GIN COCKTAILS

    • THE 22

  • NEWS
    • Laddie Whisky News >

    • The Botanist Gin News >

  • EVENTS
    • Whisky Tasting Events >

    • Foraged Gin Tasting Events >

  • SHOP
  • Search
  • Menu

DIALOGOS Debate: Angus MacRaild

IN Making Whisky 4th February 2019/by Christy McFarlane
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Google+
  • Share by Mail

Ever opinionated whisky expert Angus MacRaild gave us his personal take on the ideal age of single malt Scotch. The following article was commissioned by the distillery but has remained unedited in the spirit of presenting an unbiased view:

A big part of what inspires love for fine alcohols is their relationship to time. Time spent in their
creation. Time taken to appreciate them, both in anticipation and eventual consumption. In drinking
them we claim a little of all that time for ourselves, we think on the journey that got them to our
glass and the people and places that gave them accent and personality. It’s the closest we can get to
‘buying’ ourselves time. Apart from the hedonism of intoxication, a fragrant glass full of stories and
time is the other edge of alcohol’s decadent allure.

For non-distilled alcohols such as wine a large part of the ‘time’ aspect is patience. The best wines
express a unique annual culmination of geology, weather and winemaking that grows stronger and
more defined with cellaring. Until they peak, waver and gradually fade. Increasingly, many beers
are being considered, and ‘cellared’, in a similar fashion. For stauncher drinks such as whisky,
however, concepts such as age and time remain lopsidedly in the remit of the producer, not the
consumer, and are thus more contentious.

Much of the endless debate that has arisen around NAS (non age statement) whiskies in recent
years is because the industry spent decades telling the consumer that age was important. Years were
counted, described as ‘long’ and ‘slow’ and age statements carried an accordingly ascending price
tag. The age of a whisky bestowed it with implication and meaning. It was an understandable
approach, Scotland’s bonded warehouses bristled for much of the 20th century with an
embarrassment of riches. A mature treasure trove which, unsurprisingly, provided a springboard for
a swift and far-reaching embrace of Scottish single malts towards the turn of the millennium. The
resultant push back by an industry with dwindling stocks and the ensuing arguments about
embracing ‘flavour led’ whiskies and age being ‘just a number’ were inevitable.

NAS whiskies went from being the ‘introduction’ or ‘statement’ bottling in a single malt range, to a
‘composition’. A bottling which justified its higher price tag by way of the ‘blender’s art’; age was
increasingly talked down. However, a lesser discussed result of this debate was that it distracted
from the idea of single malts as having an ‘ideal age’. A point, not unlike the drinking window of a
wine, where a specific malt really shines. It’s notable that the big names from companies which
maintained age-statement based ranges, often talk about their favourite expression in terms of it
‘being the perfect age’ for their whisky. David Stewart has professed such for Balvenie 21 Port
Wood, just as the Grants of Glenfarclas often do for their 15 year old. It’s also a concept which is
discussed frequently and with fervour in the circles of whisky geekdom.

One of the great straw man arguments by proponents of NAS whiskies is that old whiskies are
misconstrued as being better. The reality is that old whiskies can be, and frequently are, excellent.
They are not, however, uniquely representative of a specific distillery’s style. They are often not
the very best expressions of the distillery in question. And they are certainly not the only type of
whisky consumers are crying out for. In fact, proponents of age statements frequently site the
prevalence of younger bottling ages – 5 and 8 years old – that were common in commercial malt
whiskies of the 1980s and earlier decades.

Indeed, the opportunity to taste whiskies from a single distillery from 5 up to 30 years of age is
greatly illuminating. The segregation of information provided by the different ages builds a vivid
picture of the life and evolution of distillery character. Malts like Clynelish sang beautifully at 5
years of age when they were bottled as such in the 1970s. Glenfiddich at 8 years old was similarly
excellent. Recently a Benromach at 5 years old personified the best qualities of youth in malt
whisky. Just as a 1980s bottling of Balblair 5 year old felt thin and lacking at such tender years.
Whatever the perception of quality, these youngster bottlings provide a benchmark from which to
found impressions. The older sibling bottlings add colour and richness to this impression.

Over the years I’ve formed fairly thorough opinions – and I’m not alone in doing so – about most
distilleries and their respective ‘peak’ ages. Balvenie needs at least 15 years; Glen Grant can work
at 5 but is better after 30; Clynelish can hit brilliance from 5 onwards; Ardbeg struggles past 30. In
fact Ardbeg is illuminating in that sense, the impression of running out of steam after 30+ years is
something it shares with the other southern Islay distilleries and most peated makes. Peat can go to
war with the wood over time whereas it masks many sins of youth at the start of a whisky’s life.
New make spirit can be grizzly, feinty, sulphur-flecked stuff. The whole purpose of ageing is to
mature a whisky, to round the edges off and bring it out of itself so to speak. Peat gives this process
a helping hand earlier on. It’s one of the reasons why Port Charlotte, and especially Octomore, have
worked well at younger ages. They are exceptionally well made distillates but the peat drapes an
extra wee cloak over the remnant clumsiness of youth. The Octomores in particular are not cheap
bottlings but are commercial and critically successful, a success that proves age statements such as
5 can and do still work. Whether old or young, what consumers want most of all is good whisky.
Which nudges us in the direction of quality and the inescapable fact that it isn’t just about a
particular age but about ingredients as well. Shoddily produced whisky can be rescued by the right
cask and correct amount of time. Just as excessive or nasty wood will kill most whiskies eventually.
Great distillate can sing in the tiredest of refills. Bland distillate can be coloured by a clean and
generous cask. The most common complaints around older whiskies is that they are too woody,
which many are. Just as the charge against younger drams is that they simply are not ready. The
best whiskies at any age all share the triumvirate of the best ingredients, careful production and a
stately, lengthier pace of production of the initial spirit. Time expended in malting, mashing,
fermentation and distillation counts for a great deal in a whisky’s final character.

At the risk of taking a somewhat generalised stance, I do believe that Scotch Whisky has a loose
‘drinking window’ in which a majority of whiskies, out of most cask types, fall. For me it’s 12 – 20
years of age. Most of the greatest whiskies ever made sit within this timeframe. Of course there are
exceptions and even extremes of youth and age at which whisky can dazzle. But, around these ages
is where most malts seem to find firm footing, clarity of voice and achieve that most desired thing:
balance.

Popular articles from the newsdesk

VIEW ALL 12 /Barley 1 /Bruichladdich Whisky News 0 /Collaborations 0 /Edible Plants 0 /EVENTS 0 /Exploring history 0 /FAQ 0 /Flavour Science 0 /Foraged Gin Cocktails 0 /Foraged Gin Tasting Events 0 /Foraging 0 /Laddie People 1 /Making Whisky 1 /New Releases 3 /People 0 /Real Food 0 /Sustainability 0 /Terroir 0 /The Botanist Gin News 0 /The Distillery 3 /Transparency 3 /Whisky Tasting Events 0
A Research Project into Whisky Maturation
Making Whisky

A Research Project into Whisky Maturation

8th December 2012/by Carl Reavey
whisky casks
Transparency

What are the sizes of whisky casks we use?

15th August 2012/by Carl Reavey
Bruichladdich Bere Barley 2008
New Releases

Global launch of Bruichladdich Bere Barley 2008: Islay Grown

30th November 2017/by Carl Reavey
LaddieMP3 live whisky tasting - cheers
Transparency

LaddieMP3 Goes Down Well

27th November 2015/by Jane Carswell
Bruichladdich Islay Barley 2010 - combine harvester barley
New Releases

The new Bruichladdich Islay Barley 2010

3rd March 2017/by Carl Reavey
ardnahoe jim mcewan
Laddie People

You cannot keep a good man down…

1st January 2017/by Carl Reavey
The iconic Whisky still has been in place since 2005
The Distillery

The Whisky still has gone. Long live the still.

5th February 2015/by Carl Reavey
The Distillery

The Laddie Open Day, Feis Ile 2013 – Ansgar & Thomas Speller

27th May 2013/by Carl Reavey
Sara Parkin visits ‘ Domaine des Hautes Glaces ’
Transparency

Sara Parkin visits ‘ Domaine des Hautes Glaces ‘

8th August 2017/by Sara Parkin
Bairds malt - Barley Plots Mark Kinsman
Barley

Bairds Malt of Inverness

29th August 2017/by Carl Reavey
Working with 'Crows Nest Films'
The Distillery

Working with ‘Crows Nest Films’

23rd April 2013/by Carl Reavey
PC12
New Releases

Port Charlotte PC12 Launched

14th January 2015/by Carl Reavey
Load more
You are here: Home / News / Bruichladdich Whisky News / Making Whisky / DIALOGOS Debate: Angus MacRaild
© BRUICHLADDICH DISTILLERY, ISLAY.Triman Logo
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Mail
  • CONTACT
  • TRADE
  • TERMS
  • PRIVACY
DIALOGOS Debate: Greg Dillon DIALOGOS Debate: Greg Dillon DIALOGOS Debate: A Legacy in the Making DIALOGOS Debate: A Legacy in the Making
Scroll to top
Bruichladdich Distillery
Due to regulations in your own country of residence, you cannot access this website

By entering you accept the use of cookies to enhance your user experience and collect information on the use of the website. Find out more

WMD – THE STORY OF THE YELLOW SUBMARINE HAS BEEN FULL OF CHARACTER AND CHARACTERS RIGHT FROM THE BEGINNING.

It started with our friend ‘Demolition Dave’ helping Duncan McGillivray and his gang to demolish the old Inverleven distillery – buying up all the old equipment for scrap and loading it onto barges on the Clyde. All so Duncan had some spares to keep Bruichladdich running in the days of No Money.

As this odd flotilla was being towed round the Mull of Kintyre and up to Islay, Laddie MD Mark Reynier received an email from the Defence Threat Reduction Agency (DTRA) in the USA who had been monitoring distillery webcams on the grounds that our processes could have been ‘tweaked’ to produce the dreaded WMD. ‘Weapons of Mass Destruction’.

Never one to allow the opportunity for a good story to pass him by, or to get his beloved distillery in the news, Reynier embellished the tale, which soon grew to involve spies and the CIA and visits by weapons inspectors. All of which made great headline-grabbing copy in the febrile media atmosphere then prevailing around WMD.

One of the stills from Inverleven was dutifully set up outside the old Victorian buildings, and became an iconic sight, with a pair of Duncan’s old wellie boots sticking out of the top to represent those weapons inspectors searching for dangerous chemicals deep in its copper bottomed interior.

A special bottling was commissioned (of course) and dubbed the ‘Whisky of Mass Distinction’ (geddit?) and much hilarity ensued. At least among the Laddies, the rest of the whisky industry having long since given up on the noisily irreverent rebels.

WMDII: A YELLOW SUBMARINE

Things were about to get even more eccentric because, shortly afterwards, Islay fisherman John Baker was heading home to Port Ellen when he spotted something awash in the sea off the bow of his boat. Being a resourceful man, he attached a rope to said object and towed it into the pier where Gordon Currie lifted it out of the water. It proved to be a very beautiful yellow submarine.

Very conveniently, the yellow vessel had ‘Ministry of Defence’ and a telephone number stencilled on it, which was of course immediately called. What happened next was to become the stuff of legend. He was connected to the Royal Navy. “I have found your yellow submarine” said John. “We haven’t lost a yellow submarine” said the Navy. Which was an odd response as the evidence to the contrary was overwhelming.

John and Gordon then loaded the submarine onto a lorry and took it to a secret location in Port Ellen (actually fellow fisherman Harold Hastie’s back garden). The local newspaper was called, then the nationals, and the following day the red-tops were full of pictures of the two friends astride the lethal-looking machine, carrying fishing rods, and asking: “Has anybody lost a yellow submarine?”

Hilarious… unless you were the Royal Navy – who did eventually admit to it being theirs. HMS Blyth, the minesweeper that lost it, eventually came to pick it up, slipping into the pier at dawn to winch it aboard. By that time, Bruichladdich had (of course) commissioned another bottling, WMD2: The Yellow Submarine, and a box of lovely liquid was graciously offered, and accepted by the captain as a goodwill gesture.

JOIN US FOR EXCLUSIVE NEWS & WHISKIES

STAY IN TOUCH WITH US HERE ON ISLAY - NEW & EXCLUSIVE BOTTLINGS, LOCAL EVENTS, DIGITAL TASTINGS AND OTHER LADDIE MAGIC.
Email address
By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions. You are free to unsubscribe at any time.

Terms & Conditions | Privacy
MENU
  • PHILOSOPHY
      BACK
    • Progressive

    • Hebridean

    • Distillers

  • BRUICHLADDICH
  • PORT CHARLOTTE
  • OCTOMORE
  • THE BOTANIST
      BACK
    • THE BOTANIST GIN

    • WILD. FORAGED. DISTILLED.

    • FORAGED GIN COCKTAILS

    • THE 22

  • NEWS
      BACK
    • Laddie Whisky News >

    • The Botanist Gin News >

  • EVENTS
      BACK
    • Whisky Tasting Events >

    • Foraged Gin Tasting Events >

  • SHOP