Home
Up
Tastings - The 10
Tastings - The Fifteen
Tastings - The XVII
Tastings - The Twenty
Tastings - Vintage 1984
Tastings - Vintage 1973
Tastings - Vintage 1970
Tastings - Legacy 1966

Previous Reviews

Select from the list on the left hand side to read the tasting reviews.

"In Wine International Magazine January 2004 Dave Broom defended the idea that the whisky industry was clueless about wood and recommended (amongst others) our 1973 as one where wood played a vital role in the overall character - showing 'classic balance between wood and distillery character'."

The latest tasting reviews for the Murray McDavid Mission range from Malt Advocate

Click here to read the PDF

The Spirit Journal September 2003 Review

Murray McDavid Laphroaig 1988

Murray McDavid Macallan 1990

Murray McDavid Mortlach 1990

Click here to read the PDF

The latest tasting reviews for the Murray McDavid Mission range from Malt Advocate

Click here to read the PDF

Latest Tasting Notes for Murray McDavid

by Malt Maniac's Serge Valentin

http://www.maltmadness.com/mm06.html#06-08

Silver Medal for MMcD Laphroaig 1988

Read the report which appeared in the May issue of Scottish Field

Murray McDavid No 1

A global group of whisky aficionados, The Malt Maniacs, have classified their tasting notes in order of appreciation.  And guess what?  Out of 3000 tasting notes, Murray McDavid came top - even ahead of the Official Bottlings.  This highlights the strength of the Murray McDavid 'The Sum of The Parts....' policy: by assembling five casks (selected already for their quality) a more harmonious, balanced and profound whisky is obtained - better than the individual 'single cask' components.

The results:

86,80    Murray McDavid

86,24    Douglas Laing

86,20    Adelphi

84,86    United Distillers Rare Malts

84,75    Mckillop's Choice

83,33    Milroys

81,79    Coopers Choice

81,04    Cadenhead

80,67    John McArthur

80,50    Official Bottling

80,15    Flora & Fauna

80,09    Signatory Vintage

79,24    Gordon & Macphail

78,75    Dieter Kirsch

77,53    Chieften's Choice

76,80    Hart Brothers

76,39    Ultimate Collection